review: iroshizuku fuyu-gaki – a winter persimmon perfect for summer

I didn’t try the legendary Iroshizuku ink until quite recently when a pen friend sent me a sample of the shin-ryoku. Since this ink is both legendary and expensive – now even more so since Pilot’s price increase – the expectations are high and my judgement harsher than with a cheaper ink. An ink in this price range – what do they put in it to make it so expensive?!? – is not supposed to perform less than top-notch.

I seldom find it necessary to mention the bottle, but in this case I actually find it appropriate to do so since the bottle in itself is a exquisite combination of aesthetics and function. Unlike Caran d’Aches beautiful, but so very impractical bottles, these bottles are – in accordance with the Japanese tradition – made to be used as well as please the eye. The little crater in the middle shows that the designers know what fountain pen users want: a possibility to fill the pen even when the ink level is very low. I like that very much and that in itself actually adds some extra value to the iroshizuku line; the bottle can be used as an inkwell when the original ink is gone.

Some might remember that I was slightly disappointed in the shin-ryoku. It is not a bad ink, but the “wow” that I think one should feel when using such an expensive and widely acclaimed ink didn’t just wasn’t there. This has – on the other hand – been on my list of “would very much like to try” inks for quite some time, so I was thrilled to try it.

This colour is quite hard to describe. I’d say that it is a little too bright and orangey to be vermillion and too red to be a regular orange. It also has a very special hue of apricot that softens it and takes the edge out of it without making it meek or like a pastel. This makes it easier on the eyes and thus suitable even for letters if one wants to cheer up the recipient. What I did notice is that it is duller on a porous and creamy paper as the Moleskine below since it absorbs the colour and thus deprive it from a lot of shading compared to when it is used on a white paper with better quality (above). This is an ink that is much more vibrant and exciting when used on a paper and in a nib that lets it shade and shine. I really like this, slightly dreamy, dark orangish-red colour – it is original in a way that I expected of an ink with this rep and price.

Beside the colour it also features some real nice characteristics: the flow and lubrications is excellent. The Rotring Artpen with a 2.7 mm broad italic nib is somewhat dry, tired and picky with inks and it wrote wetter and better with any other ink I’ve tried in it so far. It didn’t hesitate or skip and that ought to be a good verdict of lube and flow. The non-picky Talentum also liked this ink and, since it is a wetter nib, the ink shaded beautifully in the Talentum’s italic nib – they got on very well together.

Looking at the other writing properties it gets a very good grade as well. Its bleed through on Moleskine is bad – but so are basically all inks in a broader nib. The good news is that even if it bleeds through on Moleskine paper it still only shows very minor – almost none – feathering;  despite the use of broad nibs. On paper of better quality than the Moleskine – the featured sketch paper, Rhodia, Habana and ordinary copy paper etc – it shows basically no feathering at all and very modest bleed through tendencies – even with broader nibs. It is thus both well behaved inside the pen – flow – and on paper.

In all this is thus an excellent ink with an original colour in a bottle that is both beautiful and functional. If it is worth the price? I think that is hard to say, actually. If one wants the colour badly enough (and it is original) it is an ink of very high quality, but I have yet to decide if I think the price can be justified in the long run. But, I am happy to have it and I love the colour. The big drawback is thus the price.

Advertisements

About dandelion

perpetually moving
This entry was posted in aurora, diamine, fountain pens, inks, iroshizuku, moleskine, paper, pens, photo, pilot, reviews, rotring, summer, writing and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to review: iroshizuku fuyu-gaki – a winter persimmon perfect for summer

  1. Pingback: one year with lady dandelion – anniversary give away! | lady dandelion

  2. Lyn says:

    Thank you for the review! The color is certainly beautiful and one of a kind. I have been eyeing one of the Iroshizuku colors for a while myself – Konpeki, a deep blue which washes to fluorescence.

    If you find yourself after another color, you might try purchasing on Jetpens.com, where the inks are $28, plus free shipping (over $25). Slightly less of a punch to the pocketbook. :)

  3. ToasterPastry says:

    I found this ink to be bright in color, but it feathered way too much for daily use. I am not fortunate to use only Clairefontaine paper. Hence, I would only recommend the ink if you like doing reviews on ink.

    • dandelion says:

      Interesting to hear that you have had problems with feathering. I actually did the review in a Moleskine to see if it passed the feathering test since it had behaved so nicely on the various papers I’ve tried. I’ll update if I find new problems with this ink – absolutely.

  4. Palimpsest says:

    A great review. Tempted to buy. So how expensive is expensive?

  5. eslemexe says:

    I buy this one months ago and I was waiting for a pen which would match. Than I see some photos of a Pelikan M205 Clear Demo with this ink in FPN and immediately I search for one. Now this exactly pen arrived and I’m looking for a excuse for ink it

  6. Dizzy Pen says:

    Lady D, great review as always. I have this ink in a Pilot Prera (f) right now. Boy does it make a great editing ink. I agree with most everything you’ve said. One thing I have noticed is that this ink is making my Prera write a bit fatter. Have you noticed any line spread?

    I agree that it is a very unique color, but I do have a substitute suggestion. If you can deal with a touch more pink in your orange Diamine Coral is an equally well-behaved substitute.

    • dandelion says:

      :D Thank you so much! I haven’t noticed that it makes the writing fatter, but that might be because I haven’t put it in a fine nib yet. I think I am more width conscious with F/EF nibs, so I’ll definitely try that. I have yet to try the Diamine Coral, but I must admit that I’m unsure if I’d like more pink in this :)

  7. Pingback: Tweets that mention review: iroshizuku fuyu-gaki – a winter persimmon perfect for summer | lady dandelion -- Topsy.com

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s